Short Answer

The model sees potential mispricing for the most likely outcome of Positive Growth, with model probability at 0.4% versus the market's 64.0%, suggesting the market significantly overestimates the S&P finishing positive this year.

1. Executive Verdict

  • S&P 500 2026 EPS is projected between $311 and $313.
  • Robust economic growth and Fed easing are key positive catalysts.
  • AI adoption expected to significantly boost corporate productivity and profits.
  • Non-mega-cap tech sectors currently face extreme bearish sentiment.
  • Q4 2025 corporate stock buybacks totaled $249.0 billion.

Who Wins and Why

Outcome Market Model Why
Positive Growth 65% 0.4% The moderately negative Logit-shift of -0.8 was applied because forward-looking concerns about tech sector profitability and growth now outweigh the positive, but backward-looking, data from the recent earnings season.

Current Context

Mixed sentiment prevails, reflecting cautious optimism and significant concerns about the S&P 500's trajectory for the year, influenced by ongoing earnings season and macroeconomic factors. Recent trading saw the S&P 500 decline over 1.2% on February 3, 2026, continuing a slide on February 4 as technology stocks tumbled, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed near a record high. Julian Pineda of FOREX.com highlights a growing sense of neutrality and indecision in the S&P 500, attributing recent weakness to a neutral central bank stance and mixed earnings. The fourth-quarter 2025 earnings season is underway, with approximately 33% of S&P 500 companies having reported. While about 75% of these firms beat earnings expectations, this rate is below historical averages, largely because analysts had raised forecasts. Major tech earnings have seen mixed reactions, with Apple reporting strong revenue but only a modest 6% stock gain, and Microsoft surpassing revenue expectations yet seeing its stock fall about 15% due to increasing concerns over AI costs and delayed monetization. Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) shares plunged 17.3% on February 4 following a disappointing outlook, impacting other semiconductor stocks. Macroeconomically, a government shutdown as of February 2, 2026, is delaying key economic data releases, including the jobs report, while the Federal Reserve held interest rates steady at 3.5% to 3.75% during its January meeting, marking the first time rates were not cut after three consecutive reductions.
Investors scrutinize tech growth, monitoring key reports and economic indicators for future direction. There is a noted "brutal wipeout" in software stocks driven by fears of "AI disruption," leading to a rotation out of legacy growth stocks into more defensive and cyclical sectors. This concern is echoed by Charlie McElligott of Nomura, who suggests investors are facing the "second-order impact of 'AI disruption'" affecting company bottom lines. Investors are closely watching upcoming earnings reports, particularly from major tech firms like Alphabet and Amazon this week, and Nvidia mid-month, with scrutiny on whether growth justifies significant capital expenditures in AI. Alongside earnings, key data points include job growth (forecasted at a slow average of 57,000 jobs per month for Q1 2026, though the January report is delayed) and inflation reports, following a warmer-than-expected December wholesale inflation report. The Federal Reserve's future interest rate decisions remain critical, with markets currently pricing in a neutral rate outlook for at least the next two Fed meetings. Nicholas D. Savino revised his S&P 500 forecast on February 3, predicting a market low around February 5, followed by a rally to new all-time highs extending through February 17, then anticipating choppy trading for the rest of the month.
High valuations and historical trends raise concerns about market stability and future returns. Current S&P 500 valuations are a point of discussion, with some analysts noting a high forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 22x (Goldman Sachs) or 26x earnings (IG). While Goldman Sachs projects a 12% total return for the S&P 500 in 2026, driven by economic growth, robust profits, and AI productivity, J.P. Morgan Global Research also maintains a positive outlook, forecasting double-digit gains for global equities and 13-15% above-trend S&P 500 earnings growth from AI over the next two years. However, Chris Beauchamp of IG cautions that while a positive January (S&P 500 gained 1.3%) typically signals a strong year, 2026 is a midterm election year, which historically has been the weakest for U.S. stocks, with an average return of only 4.6% and over half ending negatively. Common questions also revolve around the sustainability of tech and AI growth, the impact of elevated borrowing costs, potential recession fears (80% of Americans surveyed in December 2025 expressed concern for 2026), market breadth concentration, and geopolitical events. Upcoming events include the next Federal Reserve meeting in mid-March and the U.S. Midterm Elections in November 2026.

2. Market Behavior & Price Dynamics

No historical price data available.

3. Market Data

View on Kalshi →

Contract Snapshot

Contract details not available.

Available Contracts

Market options and current pricing

Outcome bucket Yes (price) No (price) Implied probability
Positive Growth $0.65 $0.38 65%

Market Discussion

Debates surrounding the S&P 500's performance for the current year, 2026, largely reflect a cautious optimism driven by continued earnings growth, anticipated Federal Reserve rate cuts, and robust expansion in the AI sector . However, significant concerns persist regarding elevated market valuations and the high concentration of the index in a few mega-cap technology companies, with some historical analyses suggesting a flatter market or potential correction, especially in a midterm election year . There is also discussion around the sustainability of AI-driven earnings and the potential for a broader market leadership beyond the "Magnificent Seven".

4. What is the Outlook for S&P 500 2026 EPS Estimates?

S&P 500 2026 EPS Consensus$311-$313 (as of early February 2026)
Implied 2026 EPS Growth14.3%
Projected 2026 EPS Range (Mar 2026)$314 - $318 (Base Case)
The S&P 500 full-year 2026 EPS is projected between $311 and $313. The S&P 500 full-year 2026 earnings per share (EPS) consensus is currently projected between $311 and $313, reflecting an implied year-over-year growth rate of 14.3%. Recent upward revisions, including a 0.4% increase to $311.12, are primarily driven by the Information Technology sector, particularly the "Magnificent 7" (Mag7) cohort, which is expected to achieve approximately 23% earnings growth in 2026. With the market's current forward 12-month Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio elevated at 22.2x, strong earnings performance is already priced in, necessitating sustained growth to justify existing valuations.
Strong Q4 2025 earnings established a higher base for 2026. The Q4 2025 earnings season concluded stronger than anticipated, achieving a blended earnings growth rate of 11.9%, significantly surpassing the 8.3% estimated prior. This robust performance saw 75% of S&P 500 companies reporting positive EPS surprises, coupled with a notably positive Q1 2026 guidance ratio of 17 positive to 7 negative. Such strong Q4 results establish a higher earnings base for 2026 and confirm continued strength in key growth sectors, providing a solid foundation for further upward revisions to full-year 2026 estimates.
Modest upward revision to 2026 EPS is expected despite headwinds. While the macroeconomic landscape presents a mixed picture, including projected global growth of 3.1% and US GDP growth of 2.1% in 2026, potential headwinds consist of rising interest rates, forecasted around 6.5%, and persistent inflation, estimated at 3.8%. Despite a historical disconnect between analyst forecasts and macroeconomic models, the overwhelming evidence from the Q4 2025 earnings season strongly supports a modest upward revision of the S&P 500's 2026 forward EPS estimate by the end of March 2026, likely settling within the $314 - $318 range. This projected increase is crucial for substantiating the market's current high valuation and supporting positive overall performance for the index in 2026.

5. Will RSP/SPY Ratio Decline Signal Deteriorating Market Breadth in 2026 Q1?

RSP/SPY Price Ratio0.292
RSP Early Q1 2026 Return3.66%
Normalized RSP/SPY 200-day MA0.995
The Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP) and the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) are crucial market breadth indicators. SPY is weighted by market capitalization, meaning its performance is largely dictated by a few mega-cap stocks, whereas RSP equally weights all S&P 500 constituents, reflecting the average stock's performance. From 2023 through 2025, SPY significantly outperformed RSP, primarily due to the strong performance of a small cohort of mega-cap companies. However, early in Q1 2026, a potential reversal has emerged, with RSP returning 3.66% compared to SPY's 1.12% gain, hinting at a nascent shift towards broader market participation.
The RSP/SPY price ratio is a critical indicator for overall market health. This ratio, currently around 0.292, has a normalized 200-day moving average of 0.995. A sustained breach below this 200-day moving average would signal a significant deterioration in market breadth, indicating that market leadership is once again narrowing to a few large-cap stocks. Conversely, if the ratio holds above this level or rebounds, it would suggest a broadening of market participation. The future trend of this ratio is heavily influenced by macroeconomic factors; bullish scenarios would make a sustained break less likely, while bearish conditions would render it highly probable. A volatile, sideways market could also result in temporary breaches without establishing a sustained downtrend.

6. How Do Recent Reports Influence Fed Rate Cut Probabilities by June 2026?

Jan 28 FedWatch Hold Probability>97%
Jan 2026 ADP Private Payrolls+22,000
Dec 2025 Nonfarm Payrolls+50,000
Market anticipated June 2026 rate cut before recent data shifts. Before early February 2026, market expectations strongly indicated a high likelihood of at least one 25-basis-point interest rate cut by the June FOMC meeting, with a consensus to maintain rates at the January meeting and forward-looking expectations for two cuts in 2026 starting in June . This period was followed by an information vacuum due to the delay of the January 2026 jobs report , which also includes annual benchmark adjustments .
Weak ADP data shifted market sentiment towards earlier rate cuts. The information vacuum was partially addressed by weak January 2026 ADP private payroll data, which showed an increase of only 22,000 jobs , significantly missing forecasts. This weak proxy data promptly altered market sentiment, leading advisors to suggest that such confirmation by the official BLS report could "fast-track rate cuts" . The importance of the delayed official jobs report is further amplified by its inclusion of annual benchmark revisions, which could retroactively reveal a weaker 2025 labor market and thereby strengthen the argument for a dovish Federal Reserve stance .
Upcoming CPI data will critically determine future rate cut probabilities. The cumulative probability for a June 2026 rate cut will be critically influenced by the upcoming February 2026 Consumer Price Index (CPI) report. Should cooler-than-expected inflation combine with weak jobs data, the likelihood of a June 2026 rate cut could approach 100%, potentially even accelerating expectations for a May cut. Conversely, if the CPI data comes in hotter than anticipated, it would likely temper dovish sentiment and reduce the probability of a June cut.

7. Why is Tech Sentiment Extremely Bearish Despite Broad Market Optimism?

IGV Risk Reversal Skew-8.0 to -9.5 vols (First week of February 2026)
SMH Risk Reversal Skew-10.0 to -12.0 vols (First week of February 2026)
S&P 500 Short-Term OutlookExpected to reach 5,900 or above by February 17th
Extreme bearishness plagues non-mega-cap tech sectors currently. As of early February 2026, non-mega-cap software (IGV) and semiconductor (SMH) stocks are exhibiting severe bearish sentiment, evidenced by their 90-day 25-delta risk reversal skew reaching multi-year lows. Specifically, IGV's skew is approaching panic levels last seen in March 2020, while SMH's skew, ranging from -10.0 to -12.0 vols, signifies acute market fear for the semiconductor sector. This starkly contrasts with broader market indicators, where S&P 500 prediction markets anticipate a rally to new all-time highs by mid-February 2026 and robust 14.2% earnings growth for the year.
This divergence signals a potential contrarian investment opportunity. The significant split suggests that while market participants are aggressively pricing severe downturns for non-mega-cap tech, the broader market narrative points to a 'broadening out' of leadership beyond mega-caps, with small-caps demonstrating strength. Historically, such extreme negative skew levels have frequently acted as reliable contrarian indicators, marking points of maximum pessimism just before a significant rebound, a pattern observed during the market troughs of 2009, 2016, and 2020. This implies the current bearishness in IGV and SMH options may be overextended, presenting a significant contrarian opportunity.
Sentiment normalization is highly probable by Q2 2026. Based on historical analogs and the mean-reverting nature of options skew, quantitative analysis suggests a 65-75% probability that the IGV/SMH risk reversal skew will normalize (move above -4.0) by the end of Q2 2026. This potential sentiment inversion creates opportunities for sentiment arbitrage, utilizing options strategies like put ratio spreads or risk reversals designed to profit from the current asymmetric pricing of fear in these technology sub-sectors.

8. How Do Q4 2025 Buybacks Impact S&P 500 in 2026?

Estimated Q4 2025 Buybacks$249.0 billion
Full-Year 2025 Buyback ProjectionUp to $1.1 trillion
Mid-2025 Cumulative Authorization$750 billion
Corporate stock buyback expenditures reached approximately $249.0 billion in Q4 2025. Corporate stock buyback expenditures in the fourth quarter of 2025 are estimated to have reached approximately $249.0 billion, reflecting strong corporate confidence. This substantial spending contributed to a projected record for full-year 2025 executed buybacks, which are anticipated to approach $1 trillion, with some estimates reaching as high as $1.1 trillion, representing a significant increase from the prior year. This estimated Q4 2025 figure also represents a 9.61% increase over the average of the preceding twelve quarters, indicating a sustained high level of corporate capital return.
Corporations hold substantial approved but unexecuted buyback authorization capacity. While a comprehensive total for newly announced corporate stock buyback authorizations during Q4 2025 earnings season is not explicitly provided, the broader trend of authorizations remains robust. By mid-2025, S&P 500 cumulative stock buyback authorizations had already amassed a record $750 billion, highlighting a considerable amount of approved but unexecuted repurchase capacity. Notable individual company authorizations, such as General Motors' new $6 billion program, further demonstrate the broad-based nature of this trend across diverse sectors.
Substantial buyback activity creates a powerful structural 'market bid'. The substantial volume of both buyback authorizations and expenditures carries significant implications for equity market dynamics in 2026. Following earnings blackout periods, a powerful structural 'market bid' emerges from corporations repurchasing their own shares. This creates a persistent, often price-insensitive demand source for equities, acting as a crucial stabilizing force against market drawdowns and potentially amplifying positive momentum. This ongoing corporate buying pressure is expected to serve as a significant structural tailwind, fundamentally improving the probability of a positive return for the S&P 500 over the course of 2026.

9. What Could Change the Odds

Key Catalysts

Several factors could drive positive market performance in 2026, potentially pushing the S&P 500 higher. Goldman Sachs anticipates a 12% rally, fueled by robust economic growth and continued monetary policy easing from the Federal Reserve. Artificial intelligence (AI) adoption and investment are expected to significantly boost corporate productivity and profits, with J.P. Morgan Global Research estimating AI to drive 13-15% above-trend earnings growth for at least two years. Analysts project strong corporate earnings growth for S&P 500 companies, with FactSet forecasting a 15.0% year-over-year increase, and Goldman Sachs specifically predicting a 12% rise in earnings per share. Additionally, potential Federal Reserve rate cuts, spurred by softening inflation, could further stimulate the economy by lowering borrowing costs and encouraging investment.
Conversely, several significant headwinds could dampen market sentiment and lead to negative performance. Historically, 2026, being a U.S. midterm election year, presents a challenge, as these years have typically been the weakest in the presidential cycle for U.S. equities, with an average intra-year drawdown of 18% and a 70% probability of a correction. Stock valuations remain elevated, with the S&P 500's forward P/E ratio at 22x, increasing vulnerability if corporate earnings fail to meet high expectations. Geopolitical uncertainty, including potential economic downturns, geoeconomic confrontation, and environmental risks, are highlighted by the World Economic Forum's 'Global Risks Report 2026' as major concerns. Furthermore, potential U.S. government shutdowns, policy shocks, and a crowded bullish consensus could contribute to increased market volatility and larger drawdowns from market highs.

Key Dates & Catalysts

  • Strike Date: January 01, 2027
  • Expiration: January 08, 2027
  • Closes: January 01, 2027

10. Decision-Flipping Events

  • Trigger: Several factors could drive positive market performance in 2026, potentially pushing the S&P 500 higher.
  • Trigger: Goldman Sachs anticipates a 12% rally, fueled by robust economic growth and continued monetary policy easing from the Federal Reserve [^] .
  • Trigger: Artificial intelligence (AI) adoption and investment are expected to significantly boost corporate productivity and profits, with J.P.
  • Trigger: Morgan Global Research estimating AI to drive 13-15% above-trend earnings growth for at least two years [^] .

12. Historical Resolutions

No historical resolution data available for this series.