Short Answer

Both the model and the market expect Johnny Depp to be cast in the next Pirates of the Caribbean, with no compelling evidence of mispricing.

1. Executive Verdict

  • Disney's Alan Bergman has not publicly addressed rehiring Johnny Depp.
  • Jerry Bruckheimer no longer holds Pirates of the Caribbean casting rights.
  • A Margot Robbie-led Pirates of the Caribbean film is actively developing.
  • Johnny Depp's audience favorability declined significantly after his 2022 trial.
  • Multiple scripts for Pirates of the Caribbean 6 are currently under development.

Who Wins and Why

Outcome Market Model Why
Johnny Depp 48.0% 50.0% While producers have publicly expressed a desire and planning for Johnny Depp's return, Depp himself stated in 2022 that he would not work with Disney again, and Disney has recently shown caution with controversial talent, leading to a slight positive shift given the producer's active planning.

2. Market Behavior & Price Dynamics

Historical Price (Probability)

Outcome probability
Date
This prediction market is characterized by a prolonged sideways trend, indicating significant uncertainty and a lack of consensus among traders. The price has been confined to a relatively narrow 10-point channel, with a clear support level established around 42.0% and a resistance level at 52.0%. The current price of 48.0% sits near the midpoint of this range. The absence of any significant price spikes or sustained movements is consistent with the lack of new information or major news developments that would provide a catalyst to shift market sentiment decisively in one direction.
The total trading volume of 1,483 contracts, distributed over 325 data points, suggests moderate but not aggressive market participation. This volume pattern, coupled with the stable price action, indicates that trading activity has not been sufficient to break the established range. Market conviction appears low, with traders seemingly in a holding pattern while awaiting a definitive announcement or credible news. The overall sentiment reflected in the chart is one of equilibrium; the market is pricing the event as nearly a coin-flip, hovering just below the 50% mark, and will likely remain range-bound until new information emerges.

3. Market Data

View on Kalshi →

Contract Snapshot

The market resolves to "Yes" if Johnny Depp is cast in the next Pirates of the Caribbean before January 1, 2035, as reported by sources such as The Hollywood Reporter, The New York Times, and the Associated Press. Otherwise, it resolves to "No" and closes by January 1, 2035, at 10:00 AM EST. The market will close and expire early if the casting event occurs before this date.

Available Contracts

Market options and current pricing

Outcome bucket Yes (price) No (price) Last trade probability
Johnny Depp $0.52 $0.55 48%

Market Discussion

Traders are primarily discussing the interpretation of the market rules, specifically whether "cast" implies any role or only a leading one, and how potential CGI or AI-generated appearances of Johnny Depp would be handled. There are no explicit arguments for or against his casting based on external factors or industry rumors. The general consensus among active participants seems to be that "cast" likely refers to any role, though the CGI/AI aspect remains an open question for clarification.

4. Has Alan Bergman Publicly Addressed Johnny Depp Re-hire Risks?

Alan Bergman StatementNo direct public statements on Johnny Depp re-hire [^]
Producer Interest in DeppProducers planning for Depp's return as Jack Sparrow [^]
Johnny Depp's StanceStated in 2022 he would not work with Disney again [^]
Walt Disney Studios Chairman Alan Bergman has not publicly commented on rehiring Johnny Depp. There are no direct public statements from Bergman regarding the brand risk or financial liability associated with such a decision [^]. This executive silence contrasts with public indications from producers linked to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, such as Jerry Bruckheimer, who have expressed a desire and plans for Depp to return as Jack Sparrow [^]. However, Johnny Depp himself publicly stated in 2022 that he would not work with Disney again [^]. Prior to his initial departure, Depp reportedly had a $22.5 million deal for Pirates 6, underscoring the significant financial commitment Disney previously had in his involvement [^].
Disney demonstrates a cautious approach to recent talent controversies since 2022. The company has reportedly navigated a situation involving Jonathan Majors, which has been characterized as its "latest 'Johnny Depp' problem," suggesting an acute awareness of the complexities and potential repercussions of such high-profile talent issues [^]. While predating the 2022 timeframe, Disney set a precedent in 2019 by re-hiring director James Gunn after a controversial firing, indicating a willingness to reconsider talent under specific circumstances [^]. The current absence of executive statements concerning Depp, coupled with Depp's own publicly expressed disinclination to return, suggests a nuanced brand and financial calculation that has not been articulated by current top Disney executives.

5. Does Jerry Bruckheimer Have Pirates of the Caribbean Casting Rights?

Disney First-Look Deal Ended2014 [^]
Paramount First-Look Deal Effective2014 [^]
Johnny Depp Return DiscussedMarch 2026 [^]
Jerry Bruckheimer's extensive first-look film deal with Disney concluded in 2014. This marked the end of a two-decade-long partnership that was reported in September 2013 not to be renewed [^]. The separation was amicable, allowing both parties to continue collaborating on ongoing projects, including the 'Pirates of the Caribbean' franchise and 'National Treasure 3' [^]. Following this, Bruckheimer established a new first-look deal with Paramount Pictures in December 2013, which became effective in 2014 [^].
Bruckheimer continues as a producer for 'Pirates of the Caribbean' despite past deal changes. Despite the conclusion of his general first-look deal, he has maintained his involvement with the franchise as a producer. However, the available research does not detail any specific contractual clauses within past or current agreements that would grant him casting consultation or approval rights for the franchise capable of overriding studio objections. While specific overriding rights are not detailed, Bruckheimer has publicly engaged in discussions regarding potential casting, such as his statement in March 2026 indicating his belief that Johnny Depp "would do it" concerning a return to the franchise [^]. Bruckheimer's enduring relationship with Disney is also highlighted by his designation as a 2026 Disney Legend [^].

6. What is the Current Status of Margot Robbie's Pirates Film?

Margot Robbie's InvolvementOngoing; "still in talks" as of February 2026, also "confirmed" by producer [^]
Writer AttachedYes [^]
Production Greenlit/Director AttachedNo director attached, budget not officially greenlit [^]
The Margot Robbie-led 'Pirates' project is actively developing [^] . This 'Pirates of the Caribbean' project is currently in an active development phase, with a writer attached to the project, indicating ongoing work on the screenplay [^]. While some reports from February 2026 state Margot Robbie is "still in talks" for her role [^], her involvement has also been confirmed by a producer [^]. These actions confirm the film is proceeding through the early stages of pre-production.
Critical pre-production milestones are not yet met [^] . Based on available research, a director has not yet been publicly attached to the Margot Robbie-led 'Pirates' project, nor has a production budget been officially greenlit [^]. These are crucial steps that typically signify a film is a high-priority for immediate production. The absence of these announcements suggests that while the project is a focus for development, it has not yet received the final production greenlight to be considered Disney's immediate priority for the "next" film in the franchise, pointing instead to ongoing script development and early planning stages.

7. How Has Johnny Depp's Audience Appeal Shifted Post-Trial?

Net Favorability Among Parents Post-Trial+1% (down from +10% pre-trial) [^]
YouGov Popularity Rating (Q1 2025)24% [^]
Gen Z Actor Ranking (2022)Not in top 10 actors [^]
Johnny Depp's favorability among American parents declined significantly post-2022 trial. His net favorability dropped from +10% before the trial to +1% following the verdict [^]. While his favorability initially saw an increase leading up to and during the trial, it experienced a substantial decrease after the verdict, suggesting a notable reduction in his perceived appeal within demographics relevant to family-oriented films [^].
Specific Q Score data for family demographics remains unavailable from key firms. While direct metrics from companies like NRG or ScreenEngine/ASI concerning Johnny Depp's appeal to the 'family'/PG-13 demographic were not available [^], broader web research offers insights into his general popularity. His overall popularity experienced a dip around mid-2022 immediately after the trial but has since shown some recovery, reaching a YouGov popularity rating of 24% as of Q1 2025 [^]. A 2022 analysis also noted that he did not rank among the top 10 actors for Gen Z, indicating his appeal varies across different age groups [^].

8. What is the development status of Pirates of the Caribbean 6 and Jack Sparrow?

Script DevelopmentMultiple scripts in development, including one by Craig Mazin and Ted Elliott [^]
Producer's Stance on Jack SparrowJerry Bruckheimer desires Johnny Depp's return, stating it is "actively being planned" [^]
Script Approval StatusNo script officially approved by Disney's story department or moved to budgeting phase [^]
Multiple scripts for Pirates of the Caribbean 6 are actively under development. Producer Jerry Bruckheimer has confirmed that the franchise is exploring several creative approaches for the upcoming film. One script, being written by Craig Mazin and Ted Elliott, remains in the pitching stage as of March 2024, with ongoing efforts to finalize its approval [^]. Concurrently, another version of the script, reportedly featuring a potential female lead, is also in development [^].
Johnny Depp's potential return as Jack Sparrow lacks official Disney approval. Jerry Bruckheimer has openly expressed his strong desire for Depp's involvement, stating in March 2024, "If it's up to me, he'll be in it" [^]. He further indicated that Depp's return is "actively being planned by the creative team" [^]. However, this planning by the production team does not signify official approval from Disney's story department for any specific script featuring Jack Sparrow. No version of the script has yet advanced to the budgeting phase, which is an essential prerequisite for initiating any official casting decisions [^].

9. What Could Change the Odds

Key Catalysts

Catalyst analysis unavailable.

Key Dates & Catalysts

  • Expiration: January 01, 2035
  • Closes: January 01, 2035

10. Decision-Flipping Events

  • Trigger: Catalyst analysis unavailable.

12. Historical Resolutions

No historical resolution data available for this series.